Tushbaby vs the other carriers I actually tested
Disclosure: I may earn a commission if you buy through my link or use my code, at no extra cost to you. This site is not run by Tushbaby. Please read the disclosure before you use the code box below. This page names other brands only to compare my own experience. It contains no link or code for any other brand.
Ashley's own photo of her Tushbaby hip carrier.
Code: TUSHASHLEY
Current discount reported on November 2, 2026: 16% off sitewide. It has reached 22% during holiday sales. Discounts change, so check the final price at checkout.
Use code TUSHASHLEY at checkout. The code is reported to work sitewide, on anything Tushbaby sells.
I did not pick Tushbaby without trying anything else. I tested other carriers first, and each one taught me something about what I actually needed. This page is my own experience, not a lab test, and not a spec sheet for the other brands. If your baby is at a different stage, a different carrier may still be the right early pick for you.
Boba Wrap
The Boba Wrap has a learning curve. You have to learn the wrap, and that takes practice at first. Once you get it, it is great for newborns and small babies, close and soft, with that wrapped in feeling that small babies seem to love.
Where it fell short for me was growth. It does not feel as supportive as your baby grows, because the fabric is very stretchy. As you get toward the heavier weight limits, it starts to feel weighed down. For a tiny baby, that stretch is a plus. For a heavier toddler, it was a limit I could feel.
Boba Bliss carrier
The Boba Bliss has two details I really liked. The shoulder strap has an adjustable shoulder strap cinch to keep fabric out of your baby's face, no matter where their face lands. And it is belted and adjustable around the waist, so you can get a fit that feels more secure than a plain wrap.
The con was the same as the Boba Wrap. The stretchy fabric does not deal well with heavy babies. That cinch and that waist belt help, but they do not change the fabric itself. Once my baby got heavier, the stretch was the story again.
Momcozy and Artipoppe style carriers
The Momcozy and Artipoppe style carriers I tried, including dupes, felt different from the Boba wraps. The fabric is thicker and more supportive feeling, and that extra structure is noticeable right away.
The limit for me was size. They have size limitations, and they do not grow well with your baby into bigger sizes. A carrier that fits beautifully at one stage can start to feel like the wrong size at the next stage, and then you are shopping again.
Ergobaby
Ergobaby was not small enough for newborns in my use. It also looks intimidating, with lots of straps, and that first look alone can put you off when you are already tired and learning a new carrier.
It felt best suited for one age, and then it quickly becomes unusable as your baby moves past that stage. The torso of the belt is too big for new babies, and at heavier weights it weighs on the upper and lower back. That combination, too big early and heavy on your back later, is why it did not last for us the way Tushbaby did.
At a glance, from my own use
| Carrier I tried | Best in my use | Limit I felt |
|---|---|---|
| Boba Wrap | Newborns and small babies, close wrap feel | Learning curve, very stretchy, feels less supportive and weighed down at heavier weights |
| Boba Bliss | Shoulder strap cinch keeps fabric out of baby's face, belted adjustable waist | Same stretchy fabric limit, does not deal well with heavy babies |
| Momcozy and Artipoppe style | Thicker, more supportive feeling fabric | Size limitations, does not grow well into bigger sizes |
| Ergobaby | Structured carrier for one stage | Not small enough for newborns, looks intimidating with lots of straps, best suited for one age and quickly unusable, torso too big for new babies and weighs on upper and lower back at heavier weights |
| Tushbaby Hip Carrier and 2 in 1 | Grows into toddlerdom, heavier weights, freer movement | Hip seat alone is not hands free, 2 in 1 is not for newborns |
Why Tushbaby won for us, in the end
At the end of the day, the Tushbaby grows with your baby all the way into toddlerdom at heavier weights. It does not require constant adjustments, and it allows your baby or toddler to move more freely. That last part matters a lot for finicky babies that want more movement and do not like feeling so restricted.
That is the tradeoff in plain terms. Wraps can feel softer and closer when a baby is tiny. Thicker structured style carriers can feel more supportive at one size. Tushbaby was the one that kept working as my baby got bigger, heavier, and more determined to move, without me having to relearn or resize a carrier every few months.
If you are at the newborn stage, start with the newborn guide and the Pearl review. If your child is already in the up and down toddler stage, read the Hip Carrier review, and if you need both hands free, read the 2 in 1 review. If you are still unsure, the carrier finder quiz will point you to the right one in four questions.
Questions about the carriers I tested
Did you test carriers other than Tushbaby?
Yes. I tested the Boba Wrap, the Boba Bliss, Ergobaby, and Momcozy and Artipoppe style carriers, including dupes, before settling on Tushbaby for the toddler stage.
Is a wrap better than Tushbaby for a newborn?
For a very small baby, a wrap can feel closer and softer. For the Tushbaby range, the Pearl Wrap is the newborn option, at 8 to 20 lbs, facing inward only.
Why did Tushbaby win for you in the end?
Because it grows with your baby all the way into toddlerdom at heavier weights, it does not require constant adjustments, and it lets a baby or toddler move more freely.